We need to tackle the REAL Hate

It has become a wide spread reaction to label anti hate activists and those who stand against prejudice as ‘politically correct’. Given the examples of racism paraded with sensationalist headline grabbing horror by the press this is perhaps not surprising. Only a few weeks ago we watched mainstream media tie itself up in knots wondering if Marks and Spencer’s bra colours are making a covert racial statement while Tesco shoppers vowed to boycott the supermarket in retaliation for sales of a child’s T shirt depicting a pretty black mermaid whose hair was apparently ‘too fluffy’. 

Headlines like this do nothing to tackle the growing problem of racism and hate in our country. If anything they actually turn people away from tackling genuine issues of inequality and prejudice. While the focus is on this nonsense the real racists are busy spewing their bile to the young and the vulnerable in an attempt to recruit and radicalise more people to their extremist way of thinking.

The problem is that racism, proper racism, has gone underground. When the big social media platforms like Twitter and Facebook wised up to the fact that they were becoming recruitment grounds for the radical far right, the extremists set up home on a series of less regulated, hate friendly alternative platforms. Racists and the like minded followed Milo Yiannapoulis to Telegram, Tommy Robinson to the Russian site VK and Katie Hopkins to Parler. Nazi group Patriotic Alternative adopted the streaming site DLive while the video upload site Bitchute became the go to place for all the bigots kicked off You Tube.

In some ways this is a good thing. Our anti hate organisation Resisting Hate have long focused on the deplatforming of hate. Removal from Telegram, Twitter and You Tube hurts even the most high profile of haters. Tommy Robinson is a prime example of this. He was preaching his Islamophobia to over a million people on mainstream channels. Deplatforming has left him with just over 35,000 followers on Telegram. He (and others) are left preaching to the converted in online echo chambers.

However there is a serious downside to the echo chambers of hate away from the glare of the mainstream. Unchecked, the extremism has flourished like a weed, creating a counter culture of which the Tesco boycotters and the indignant Marks and Spencer bra brigade are likely in total ignorance. These alternative platforms are used to promote racial hatred, genocide, Holocaust Denial and every imaginable evil of which our fellow human beings are capable.

Alternative media is used to recruit the easily led. Once inside the propaganda machine they are exposed to a diet of hatred, lies and conspiracy theories. They have hatred drilled into them. Radicalisation can occur over a very short period of time.

I’m calling for social media apps that refuse to self regulate by tackling hate speech on their platforms to be removed from Google and Apple app stores and as a last resort to be ISP blocked in the UK. In the wake of the Christchurch massacre New Zealand was able to ban sites like 4 Chan at ISP level. From a technological point of view it is very straightforward.

We know extremists are promoting racism and hatred

We know extremists are using alternative media platforms to incite violence

We know extremists are teaching lies about history, particularly regarding the Holocaust.

We know extremists are body shaming, putting the health of young people at risk

We know extremists are posting anti migrant hatred

We know extremists are promoting hatred against people with disabilities

We know Islamophobia is growing

We know anti-Semitism is rife

We know Homophobia and anti LGBT are increasing

We know dangerous lies about coronavirus are being shared

And we know that extremists are using alternative social media to recruit, brainwash and radicalise young people into their hateful world view.

The screenshots I have provided here (all genuine extracts from public chat rooms on Telegram) show the real face of hate in the modern world. As an anti hate activist it frustrates me greatly that Marks and Spencer bras make the headlines but calls to lynch, torture and murder black people go unreported. It frustrates me that there is so little education offered to parents about sites that can easily be accessed by kids.

Extremism only needs to recruit so many before it can turn the tables back and go mainstream. In this current climate with the economy in free fall, a clearly racist individual in the Prime Minister’s chair, an approaching recession, the most badly funded public services in living memory and the last ten years of Tory austerity destroying the lives of many, discontent is a fertile field for those who seek to exploit it to promote their agenda of hatred and abuse.

Instead of whining about bra colours I want to see the press tackling the real issues. I want better awareness of the filth festering on alternative platforms. I want to see these platforms regulated, banned or shut down. I want to see Google and Apple taking action, ISPs stepping up to the challenge and the media shaming known racists and the radical far right.

We tried to tackle the individuals, that didn’t work. We need to tackle the platforms.

We can start worrying about fluffy haired mermaids when we’ve succeeded in building a hate free society. Until then, we have a lot of work to do.

Roanna Carleton Taylor